I’ve always been
interested in seeing how homemade white chocolate chips macadamia nut cookies
would turn out. For the uninitiated, (and non-allergic) said cookies constitute
the most delicious variety of cookie that you can get from Subway, or most
functions catered by Aramark. These cookies lack the sweetness of chocolate
chips but make up for it with the flavourings of the macadamia nut. The
challenge of making these cookies is that their main ingredients: white
chocolate chips and the nuts aren’t something you just keep around the house
very often.
I found myself with
white chocolate chips after superstore had their decadent series of chips on
sale one week. I wasn’t sure how good they would be, but a few weeks ago I made
a batch of chocolate chip cookies for a match of Twilight Imperium (which I
regretfully forgot to document for blogging purposes) and ran out of chocolate
chips and had to substitute a cup of white chips. They turned out pretty good
working in tandem with the darker chocolate (I generally don’t like white
chocolate anything) so I figured I’d try making them the star attraction.
The first challenge
was securing a bag of macadamia nuts. I knew that it is a premium nut, but I
did not know it was $13/pound premium. When I’m at the store and see that price
I thought ‘man that is expensive, but surely if I fill this tiny bag it will
only be a dollar or two’ I couldn’t have been more wrong. With my $5, 200g bag
of macadamia nuts in hand I had all the ingredients needed for these blessed
cookies, or so I thought…
A quick Google
search revealed to me a recipe that claimed would provide me with the fabled
subway cookies. I didn’t know whether they would turn exactly the same as the
sub slinging chain, but I was determined to try. The recipe used will once
again be featured at the end of this post.
I gathered all the
ingredients together when I discovered a slight error. When the recipe called
for one pound of butter I thought it was one cup. The margarine I was using
comes in ½ cup cubes and I had two left, no problem right? Until I realized
that I was about 1 cup short. On top of the fact that I had to grapple with
making cookies that may actually be worse for your health than the kind at
Subway, I also faced delays in my cookie making. Normally this wouldn’t be a
problem but I was making these cookies for the students I was working the
extended late shift on Saturday, so the delays would mean no bounty of cookies
to bring!
| It's like the action force of obesity! |
Once again I took
to the Internet (which is generally my co-chef in these endeavors, as well as
my unit converter and my crowd-sourced review of recipes, it goes quite a ways
in making me a competent chef) to solve my dilemma. It determined that in a
pinch, shortening could be used as a substitute for butter or margarine
(although usually it is the other way around), all I had to do was add a bit of
water. This is because shortening is fat or oil (usually derived from vegetable
nowadays to save arteries) and margarine is just fat plus water essentially. I
decided this would be the solution, but I confirmed with my Mom just to be
sure. She consulted with my Aunt and between the two of them they have like 60
years of baking experience and they figured I could throw in the shortening,
but without water, although they both balked at the amount of butter the recipe
was demanding. Satisfied that I was in the cooking right, I proceeded to
substitute in some shortening, although I defied my relative’s suggestion to
not add water because the all mighty Crisco box suggested I should, and I
figured a company that’s been making shortening for 50 years might know best.
For once I decided
to follow the recipe step by step. Usually I just take the ingredient list and
the general idea of how they want me to make it and go to town. I hadn’t made
these cookies before I wanted to be more conservative in my baking process. In
doing this however, I subjected myself to a number of ridiculous steps, usually
in the pursuit of ‘creaming’ the dough.
Before I could
start anything though, I had to get my measure of shortening. I can only imagine that baking companies are
run by sadists, because instead of portioning your shortening into usable
sizes, they throw in a useless ruler and tell you to cut it yourself. This
makes the default size of shortening the massive one pound block. This is
either proof that big baking is trying to make everyone fat, or that marketing
companies think that home baking is done by people with way too much time on
their hands. Add that to the fact that the block takes up all the packaging
space and only part of the shortening has a wax paper sleeve, and you’re going
to end up getting some shortening on you unless you have the precision of a
bomb defuser.
| Closer... Closer... no wait! Now you're going to have 3/7ths! You've doomed us all! |
Then comes creaming
the butter, which I don’t know if anyone has tried this by hand but it is
terrible. You take some softened butter/margarine/shortening and you stir it
around and around until it is an amorphous buttery blob that sticks to all
corners of your bowl. I don’t know who thought this was a good starting point
for baking, but it always terrifies me. I’m looking at all these nice
ingredients and the first thing I do is to create this blob of fat that battles
with me for control of the spoon I’m stirring with. I feel like I’m tampering
with the laws of nature.
| It hungers... for more ingredients |
The next step was
to add to sugar, which turns the butter blob into more recognizable dough, but
also gives it the power of a small child when it comes to who controls the
stirring spoon. There are times that I thought I was going to lose the spoon to
the dough and it would just sink into the bowl like an adventurer into
quicksand.
| The more you resist the faster you lose the spoon! |
Then the eggs,
vanilla and other wet ingredients are added, which improves the smell of the
dough. I’m sure it does countless things to flavour and consistency of the
finished product, but in terms of cosmetic effects (which are all you can tell
from pictures) it doesn’t do very much. Make sure you don’t get egg shells in
your dough, otherwise you’ll be engaged in a battle of wits against your sugary
butter concoction over who can hold onto the shells the longest.
| Looking pretty good so far... |
Once all the ‘wet’
ingredients are together, I had to add in the dry, which at this point I already
have mixed together in a separate bowl. ‘But
Ian!’ you ask ‘you told us the first step is creaming the butter!’ well I lied
because the first thing you should always do when making cookies is combine all
your dry ingredients because it’s super easy. In this case I ended up with all the flour because this recipe calls
for a ridiculous 4 ¼ cups of flour.
| Pictured: All the flour |
With the dry bowl
in hand, I added a little bit at a time. This serves two purposes, it keeps
flour from poofing everywhere when you try and stir the ingredients together,
and it makes it easier to combine the wet and dry. It has the bonus ability to
save your sanity, because if this is your first time cooking, then you might
think you’ve just ruined your cookies by adding flour. It turns into a
horrific, dry and white mess and your wet dough gets all crumbly. What you’re
witnessing is a battle of the moist, and your dough should always come out on
top.
| Oh god what have I done! I've ruined it for sure! |
When it is all
doughy again, I thought the struggle was over, but really it had just begun. More
flour goes in and the process starts all over again, and every time I thought
‘this is the time it’s all going to fall apart’. In my case I managed to get to
the final stage of cookie dough preparation: addition of the tasty bits
| It's like |
| A multi-step |
| Grieving process |
At this point my arms felt like they were
going to fall off, which apparently is just a sign I was doing it properly. For
all of those at home with fancy electric blenders you skip past the sore arms
trial, but it does not make you a better baker! At this point I had to add in
all the tasty bits, in this case macadamia nuts and white chocolate chips. I
had to chop up the macadamia nuts but as it turns out it wasn’t too difficult.
Apparently one of the features of the $5 bag of macadamia nuts is that they chop
up really well.
| 10 year old me would have had a field day |
Once all the bits
are in the dough the only thing left is eating it! This is of course, after a
brief stay in the oven. While it is tempting to consume vast quantities of
cookie dough when you bake without parental supervision, I’m pretty sure half
the joy of doing it is because parents tell you not to. When I’m on my own
baking, it just does not have the same appeal.
My new challenge is
to try to make appropriately sized cookies. The last time I tried baking all my
cookies ended up really small, which causes you to end up with way to many bite
sized cookies to store properly. As well, I attempted to keep them sort of
cookie shaped, which is hard when the default shape for cookies on the tray is
‘blobby’
| Alternatively they apparently come out heart shaped, but trust me, they do not stay that way. |
| Not pictured: Deliciousness, becuase they haven't managed a way to transmit that via photo... yet. |
Recipe: http://www.food.com/recipe/subway-white-chocolate-macadamia-nut-cookies-389301